Do you offer a free consultation for startups?

Yes. The Rhodes Law Firm offers a free initial consultation — no obligation, no pressure.

What legal services do you offer for startups and entrepreneurs?

We offer corporate formation, contract drafting, outside general counsel, IP protection, regulatory compliance, and investor agreement support for startups in Louisiana and nationally.

Do you handle divorce and child custody cases in Louisiana?

Yes. The Rhodes Law Firm provides compassionate family law representation including divorce, legal separation, child custody, child support, spousal support, and adoption throughout Louisiana.

How much does a family law attorney cost in New Orleans?

The Rhodes Law Firm offers a free initial consultation so you can understand your options before making any financial commitment. Contact us at (504) 475-0975 to get started.

Where is The Rhodes Law Firm located?

The firm is based in New Orleans, Louisiana and serves clients statewide and nationally.

How do I contact The Rhodes Law Firm?

Call (504) 475-0975 or schedule a consultation at therhodeslawfirm.com.

What is selective enforcement in an HOA or condo?

Selective enforcement occurs when an association enforces its rules or restrictions against some owners but not against others who are similarly situated — engaged in the same or similar conduct. Louisiana courts have recognized selective enforcement as a valid defense to HOA and condo enforcement actions, and in some cases as an affirmative claim for injunctive relief or damages.

How do I prove selective enforcement?

To establish selective enforcement, an owner must show: (1) the rule or restriction was not uniformly enforced; (2) other owners engaged in the same or similar conduct without being cited or fined; and (3) the differential treatment was not justified by a legitimate, non-discriminatory distinction. Evidence includes: prior enforcement records, complaints the association did not act on, photographs showing other violations the association ignored, and testimony from other owners.

Can selective enforcement be used as a complete defense?

Yes. Louisiana courts have recognized that an association's selective enforcement of a restriction can bar enforcement of that restriction against the complaining owner. If the association has consistently ignored violations by others, it may have effectively waived the restriction or may be estopped from enforcing it in a discriminatory manner.

Can selective enforcement be based on discrimination?

Yes, and that's when selective enforcement becomes most serious. If an association enforces rules differently based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability, or familial status, that enforcement violates the federal Fair Housing Act (42 U.S.C. § 3604) and the Louisiana Human Rights Act. Discriminatory enforcement exposes the association to significant liability beyond the underlying rule dispute.

What is the standard for selective enforcement in Louisiana?

Louisiana courts apply a reasonableness standard — the question is whether the association's enforcement pattern reflects a legitimate, non-arbitrary, and non-discriminatory basis for differential treatment. Arbitrary enforcement (enforcement based on personal animus toward a particular owner) and pretextual enforcement are both recognized forms of impermissible selective enforcement.

Can I sue an HOA for selective enforcement?

Yes. An owner who can demonstrate selective enforcement may seek: (1) injunctive relief barring enforcement of the rule against the owner; (2) declaratory judgment that the rule has been waived; (3) damages for improper fines previously paid; and (4) attorney's fees if the governing documents or applicable statute so provide.

What should I document if I believe I'm being selectively enforced against?

Start documenting immediately: photograph any violations by other owners that the association has ignored; request and review all enforcement records through your right to inspect association records; gather written communications from the board or manager that suggest improper motivation; and identify neighbors who can testify about the enforcement pattern.

How can associations prevent selective enforcement claims?

Associations can minimize selective enforcement exposure by: adopting written, objective enforcement standards; applying those standards uniformly; documenting enforcement decisions and the reasoning behind them; using an enforcement committee separate from the board; and conducting periodic audits of the community to ensure consistent enforcement across all properties.

HOA & Condo Law

HOA Selective Enforcement Attorney

Unequal Treatment · Arbitrary Enforcement · Defenses · Owner Remedies · Louisiana

Selective enforcement — applying HOA or condo rules against some owners but not others similarly situated — is a recognized defense and potential affirmative claim under Louisiana law. Courts have barred enforcement actions where associations failed to apply rules consistently. If an association discriminates in enforcement based on a protected characteristic (race, sex, disability, etc.), it also violates the Fair Housing Act. The Rhodes Law Firm both challenges selective enforcement on behalf of owners and counsels associations on how to avoid it. Free consultation: (504) 475-0975.

Written & Reviewed By

Jonathan M. Rhodes

Attorney at Law — The Rhodes Law Firm

Practice Areas: Condominium & HOA Law — Selective Enforcement · Last Updated: October 3, 2026

Serving: Orleans Parish, Jefferson Parish, St. Charles Parish, Louisiana

Types of Selective Enforcement

Arbitrary Selective Enforcement

Enforcing against one owner based on personal animus while ignoring identical violations by others.

Discriminatory Enforcement

Enforcing rules differently based on race, national origin, religion, sex, disability — Fair Housing Act violation.

Retaliatory Enforcement

Increasing enforcement against an owner who complained about the board, requested records, or voted against the board.

Inconsistent Architectural Standards

Approving modifications for some owners while denying identical requests from others without justification.

Attorney Commentary

"HOA disputes are rarely just about the rule being enforced — they're almost always about whether the rule was enforced the same way against everyone else. That's the selective enforcement question. When I represent homeowners in HOA disputes, the first thing I do is look at how the association has treated other owners in similar situations. Inconsistency is the most common and most preventable source of HOA litigation."

— Jonathan M. Rhodes, HOA & Condo Attorney

Speak With an HOA Selective Enforcement Attorney

Jonathan M. Rhodes represents owners challenging selective enforcement and advises associations on how to enforce consistently. Free consultation.

Schedule a Consultation (504) 475-0975

Related Condo & HOA Resources

HOA Disputes

HOA enforcement actions broadly.

Condominium Disputes

Condo-specific disputes.

Owner Rights in Condos & HOAs

Owner defenses and remedies.

Assessment & Fee Disputes

Challenging improper fines.

Condo & HOA Law Hub

All HOA & condo services.

HOA Selective Enforcement in Louisiana — FAQ

Being Treated Unfairly by Your HOA?

Selective enforcement is a recognized defense under Louisiana law. Free initial consultation.

Schedule a Free Consultation (504) 475-0975